Using Member Checking to Demonstrate Trustworthiness in Qualitative Research

When conducting research, ensuring the trustworthiness of data and findings is crucial. One method that can be used to enhance trustworthiness is member-checking. Member-checking involves returning to participants to confirm or clarify findings and interpretations of the research. This technique can enhance the credibility, dependability, confirmability, and transferability of research results. In this blog post, we will explore the benefits of member-checking and demonstrate how it can enhance trustworthiness in research.

What is member-checking?

Member-checking is a qualitative research technique that involves returning to participants to validate or confirm research findings. It can be used in a variety of ways, including reviewing transcripts, discussing findings, and sharing draft reports with participants. The purpose is to provide an opportunity for participants to provide feedback, clarify any misunderstandings, and ensure the accuracy of the research results.

The importance of member-checking

Member-checking is an essential component of ensuring the trustworthiness of research findings. Here are some of the benefits:

• Enhances credibility: Can enhance the credibility of research findings. It provides an opportunity for participants to validate the accuracy of the research results. By confirming that the findings accurately reflect their experiences, participants can provide greater confidence in the research results.
• Increases dependability: Increase the dependability of research findings by reducing the likelihood of researcher bias. By returning to participants to validate research findings, researchers can ensure that they have accurately captured participant experiences and perspectives, rather than relying solely on their own interpretations.
• Improves confirmability: Improve the confirmability of research findings. It provides an opportunity for participants to provide alternative perspectives or correct any inaccuracies in the research results. By ensuring that research findings are confirmable, researchers can provide greater confidence in the validity of their results.
• Facilitates transferability: Facilitate the transferability of research findings by ensuring that they are applicable to a broader population. By confirming that the research results accurately reflect the experiences and perspectives of the participants, researchers can increase the likelihood that the findings can be generalized to other contexts.

How to conduct member-checking

Member-checking can be conducted in a variety of ways, depending on the research context and the preferences of the participants. Here are some common methods for conducting member-checking:

• Review transcripts: One common method for conducting member-checking is to review transcripts of interviews or focus group discussions with participants. Researchers can provide participants with copies of the transcripts and ask them to review them for accuracy. Participants can then provide feedback on any inaccuracies or misunderstandings in the transcripts, and researchers can make revisions as necessary.
• Discuss findings: Another method for conducting member-checking is to discuss the research findings with participants. Researchers can share the research findings with participants and ask for their feedback on whether the findings accurately reflect their experiences and perspectives. Participants can also provide alternative perspectives or clarify any misunderstandings in the findings.
• Share draft reports: Finally, researchers can also share draft reports with participants and ask for their feedback on the research results. Participants can review the report and provide feedback on any inaccuracies or misunderstandings. Researchers can then revise the report as necessary to ensure the accuracy of the research results.

Tips for effective member-checking

To ensure effective conduct of member-checking, researchers should actively consider the following tips:

• Plan ahead: Researchers should plan for member-checking early in the research process. Ensure that there is enough time to conduct the member-checking and make any necessary revisions to the research results.
• Be transparent: Researchers should be transparent with participants about the purpose of the process and how their feedback will be used. By providing participants with clear explanations of the member-checking process, researchers can increase the likelihood that participants will be willing to provide honest and accurate feedback.
• Ensure confidentiality: Researchers should actively ensure participant confidentiality. Researchers should actively inform participants about how they will use their feedback and actively take necessary measures to maintain participant confidentiality, effectively preventing potential repercussions.
• Be open to feedback: Researchers should approach member-checking with an open mind and be receptive to feedback from participants. Feedback may challenge researchers’ interpretations or perspectives, but it is important to consider alternative perspectives and incorporate them into the research results as appropriate.

Conclusion

In conclusion, member-checking is a valuable technique that can enhance the trustworthiness of research findings. By returning to participants to validate or confirm research findings, researchers can increase the credibility, dependability, confirmability, and transferability of their results. Researchers can conduct it in a variety of ways, including reviewing transcripts, discussing findings, and sharing draft reports with participants. To ensure effective conduct, researchers should plan ahead, be transparent, ensure confidentiality, and be open to feedback from participants.

By incorporating member-checking into the research process, researchers can ensure that their findings accurately reflect the experiences and perspectives of the participants, which can increase the trustworthiness of their research results.

Looking for a tool to analyze your qualitative data? Check out Intellectus Qualitative, the ultimate platform designed to redefine your qualitative research experience. Whether you’re a novice student researcher, a faculty member, or an experienced researcher, you’ve discovered a tool that combines simplicity with the power of AI.

Take the course: Credibility, Trustworthiness, and Rigor of Qualitative Research

Written By Johanna Broussard

April 13, 2023